An Excerpt from
GOLD, SPORT, AND COFFEE PLANTING IN MYSORE
WITH CHAPTERS ON
COFFEE PLANTING IN COORG, THE MYSORE REPRESENTATIVE ASSEMBLY, THE INDIAN CONGRESS, CASTE, AND THE INDIAN SILVER QUESTION
BEING THE 38 YEARS' EXPERIENCES OF A MYSORE PLANTER
BY
ROBERT H. ELLIOT
AUTHOR OF "EXPERIENCES OF A PLANTER," "WRITTEN ON THEIR FOREHEADS," ETC.
COFFEE PLANTING IN COORG.
The British Province of Coorg consists of a mountainous
and jungly tract of country with elevations
of from about 2,700 to 3,809 feet. The last is the elevation
of the capital, Mercara, the tableland of which, for a
stretch of about 26 miles, averages about 3,500 feet. This
little province lies, as the reader will see by a glance at the
map, on the south-west border of Mysore, with which, since
its annexation, it has always been connected, and the Resident
of Mysore invariably holds the post of Commissioner
of Coorg. The population of Coorg is just over 170,000,
and its area is 1,583 square miles, or about one-fourth of
the size of Yorkshire. But, though small in extent and
population, its Rajah and people played an important part
as our allies in the war with Tippoo, and a full account of
the facts is given in the history of Coorg which has been
published in the "Mysore and Coorg Gazetteer." The history
of the country, however, which has been gathered up
by various European writers, is by no means of an alluring
character, and indeed, after the beginning of this century,
a more disgusting record of cruelty and oppression it would
be difficult to find in the annals of any country. But three
things at least the record most distinctly proves. The first
is (though this hardly requires any additional proof) that
man, though capable of being the best, is also capable of
being by far the worst of animals; the second is that, Coorg
being a sample of most of India in the times preceding
ours, the Hindoos were perfectly right in leaving few annals
behind them; and the third is that the blessings of British
rule far exceed anything that anyone could imagine who
had not read something of the condition of things in India
before we took possession of it, for we have not only conferred
on the people immeasurable positive benefits, but
relieved them from the barbarous rule of cruel oppressors.
In the case of Coorg there can be no doubt that we allowed
the Rajahs of that country to carry on their work of cruelty
and oppression towards their subjects for much too long a
period of time, and our failure to act can only be partially
excused by the fact that we were, in connection with the
war with Tippoo, under great obligation to the ancestor of
the Rajah we deposed. However, his vile oppression and
cruel murders, which exceed anything the reader could
believe to be possible, could no longer be tolerated, and in
1834 he was deposed, and his country absorbed into the
British Dominions. Since that date the general welfare
of the country was of course insured, and much of it is
now a thriving coffee field which, as I shall afterwards
show, has been of the greatest benefit to Mysore, and the
adjacent British territory. Of the history and cultivation
of coffee in Coorg, and my visits to the province, I now
propose to give some account.
After the planting season of 1857 I went with a brother
planter for a change of air to Mangalore, and from thence
we went to Cannanore—a military station about 200 miles
further down the coast—and, after a short stay there, rode
up the Ghauts into Coorg, where we found the planters
busy clearing the forest. Three years before our arrival
Mr. Fowler had opened the Mercara Estate, and in 1855
Mr. H. Mann, and Mr. Donald Stewart had begun work
on the Sumpaji Ghaut, while Dr. Maxwell opened up the
Periambadi Ghaut Estates in 1856, and in 1857 Mr.
Kaundinya founded a plantation in the Bamboo district
which lies on the eastern side of Coorg. The first European
plantation was, as we have seen, started in 1854, but
for many years previously coffee cultivation had been
carried on by natives in the Nalknaad District, though it
seems to be quite uncertain as to when or how it was first
introduced, or where the first seeds were obtained.
At first all seemed to be going well with coffee in Coorg,
and for a good many years the fatal mistake of the planters
in clearing down the whole forest, and leaving no shade
over the coffee, was not decisively apparent, and from the
lands that were thus cleared down on the above-mentioned
Ghauts, which lie on the western side of the province,
from 700 to 1,000 tons were picked annually when the
coffee was at its best. But what in "the seventies" represented
about £100,000 of valuable property, gradually became
more and more unprofitable, till at last the estates
were abandoned, and the land has now become covered
with masses of Lentana (a crawling, climbing, thorny
plant which has become a perfect plague in Coorg), amidst
which may occasionally be seen the white walls of unroofed
bungalows, and dismantled pulping houses, which testify to
the melancholy ending of the work of the planters whom I
found so busily engaged when, in 1857, I first entered
Coorg.
Some attributed the failure to the Bug, some to the Borer,
and to leaf disease, while others blamed the heaviness of
the tropical rains, which washed away the valuable surface
soil, the flight of which towards the western sea was much
expedited by weeding with the mamoty (a digging hoe),
which loosened the soil, and so prepared the way for its
more rapid disappearance. And these causes no doubt
hastened the end, but they were mainly results arising
from one great cause—the neglect to supply shade for
the coffee, and this again arose from the circumstance
that most of the pioneer planters came from Ceylon where
the coffee is planted in the open, and where shade is not
required. And this failure, owing to the neglect of shade,
had a most unfortunate effect, for it was owing to this that
Coorg naturally acquired such a doubtful coffee reputation
in the eyes of the uninformed public—a reputation
which, as I shall afterwards show, arose not from any fault
of the country as a coffee field, but solely from the fatal
mistake of attempting to plant without providing shade
for the coffee. And this mistake the planters, as we shall
see, had great difficulty in shaking off, for when they saw
the inevitable end approaching, and hastened to take up
land in the eastern part of Coorg in what is known as the
Bamboo district (because the jungle lands there consist
very largely of forest trees interspersed with clumps of
bamboos), they persisted in carrying their fatal Ceylon
system with them, and Mr. Donald Stewart, called the
Coffee King in Mincing Lane, who was a warm supporter
of planting in the open, even issued, it is said, an order to
his managers saying that if he found a single forest tree
standing (the coffee around even a single tree would have
proved him to be wrong) dismissal would follow. But
nature proved to be too strong for Mr. Stewart and those who
followed his example, and whole estates in the Bamboo
district were practically exterminated by the Borer insect.
At last the planters, warned by a long and bitter experience,
gave way all along the line, and began to imitate
the shade planters of Mysore, and shade is now as universal
in Coorg as in Mysore, and under its protection the coffee in
both countries thrives equally well. I may mention here
that the Rev. G. Richter, who is now the second oldest
resident in Coorg, took an active part in opening up the
Bamboo district, and was for some time a partner in one
of the estates. He has shown great zeal in endeavouring
to introduce new products, such as tea, cocoa, ceara rubber,
and vanilla. His manual of Coorg, I may add, is most
interesting and exhaustive.[48]
Besides the first mentioned, and now abandoned coffee
district, and the Bamboo district, there is the important
district of North Coorg, which, though it has a smaller
number of estates, certainly contains coffee that, so far as I
am able to judge, it would be impossible to surpass.
There are, in all, at present in Coorg 130 European estates,
with a total area of 32,323 acres (of which 20,000 are in the
Bamboo district), and 6,207 native estates and gardens,
aggregating in all 70,669 acres. The average production
of coffee from all these sources is estimated by competent
authorities at from 4,000 to 5,000 tons of coffee per annum,
or of a probable annual value of from £250,000 to £300,000.
The yield from a well cultivated estate averages from 3 to
4 cwt. of clean coffee per acre. Exceptional properties
there are, of course, which give higher returns than this,
and some could be quoted which give 6 to 7 cwt. on
the average, while sensational figures might be quoted as
regards some remarkable estates. But to give an account
of such exceptional estates might convey a misleading idea
of the general return to be obtained from coffee in Coorg,
though I think it well to allude to the fact that better
returns than those first mentioned can be obtained, and
have been obtained, as it is always of value to know what
particular pieces of land can do under the most favourable
circumstances, as this opens up the important question as
to whether it would not pay better to confine cultivation
on an estate to a narrow area of the best soils and situations
on it—a subject to which I shall more particularly refer
later on in this chapter.
In the case of well cultivated estates, an expenditure of
eighty rupees per acre is incurred on superintendence
and field labour, and fifty rupees an acre on manures and
their application, but in many European, and most native
estates, a total expenditure for superintendence, labour
and manures of about eighty rupees only is incurred, and
the results obtained are, of course, proportionately smaller.
The native gardens and plantations are, as a rule, worked
on the principle of taking everything that can be got out
of the land, and putting nothing into it. Were these
worked on European principles, it is hardly necessary to
say that the export of coffee from Coorg would be largely
increased.
Cattle manure, bones, oil-cake and fish constitute the
manures mainly used in Coorg. The first is universally
recognized as being the most valuable for coffee, but the
supply available in the Bamboo district (which contains, I
may remind the reader, 20,000 out of the 32,323 acres
under cultivation by Europeans), where grazing is scarce, is
so small that planters have to depend to a great extent on
the three last-named manures. Messrs. Matheson & Co.,
the owners of about 7,000 acres of coffee in Coorg, kept
for some years in their employ an analytical chemist,[49]
whose time was devoted to the analysis of soil, and the
making of experiments on their estates, with the view of
ascertaining what was best adapted for maintaining and
improving their fertility. Salts of various kinds were
experimented with, but, though the results from them
were generally favourable, they were found to be too
rapidly soluble for a climate so subject to heavy falls of
rain. In the end, after many experiments, he came to the
conclusion that the four above-mentioned manures were
the best for the climate, and that the proportion applied
should vary with the condition of the coffee. To illustrate
this point I may add that in Coorg, bones and oil-cake are
usually applied in the proportion of two of the latter to one
of the former. If, however, a field has suffered badly from
leaf disease (which destroys many of the leaves), or is not
making wood as rapidly as it ought, it is customary to
apply a larger proportion of oil-cake, or in some cases, to
put down that manure without adding any bones. On the
other hand, if there is a superabundance of wood, and it is
desirable to throw the whole energies of the tree into the
production of berries, then the proportion of bone manure
is increased and that of oil-cake diminished.
In former times all manures were applied immediately
after the crop was picked, and on estates where labour is
scarce, or comes in late in the season, this system is still
carried on. But from results actually obtained on estates
in Coorg, it has now been proved that it is more
advantageous to apply part of the manure immediately
after crop, in order to strengthen the tree when the
blossom showers fall (which they usually do in March
and April), and to aid it in perfecting and setting the
blossom, and a second portion after the heavy monsoon
rains are over, in order to assist the tree in growing fresh
wood, and in maturing the crop. The bones, oil-cake, and
fish are usually mixed with burnt earth—a cubic yard to
every five cwt. of the manure—and then scattered on the
surface of the land around the stems of the trees, and
forked in. The burnt earth, or indeed almost any good
earth, makes an admirable addition to bones, oil-cake, and
fish, for, though the first two, or the last two, furnish complete
manure for coffee, they of course cannot ameliorate
the physical condition of the soil, which, as I have fully
shown in the chapter on manures, is often of more importance
than its strictly speaking chemical condition. The
burnt earth, in short, takes the place of cattle manure as a
physical agent, and, for that purpose, I think that the soil,
is to be preferred to cattle manure, as the former would
certainly be cheaper and more lasting in its effects in
keeping the soil in a loose and easily workable condition.
On the other hand, it must be considered that cattle
manure would be more moisture-holding than ordinary
earth, though not more so than jungle top-soil, and when
first applied, would be perhaps more opening to the land,
than burnt or ordinary earth, but if the red earth
(Kemmannu), to which I have alluded in my chapter on
manures, can be obtained, that, I know from experience,
would be more cooling, and moisture-absorbing than
cattle manure.
I now turn to a point of great general interest, and one
which furnishes another illustration of what I dwelt upon
at some length in my introductory chapter, the wide-spreading
value arising from the introduction into India
of English capital which, as I have shown, develops the
agricultural resources of the country in ever-widening
circles. At first in Coorg the adjacent province of Mysore
was the only source of labour supply, but the increased
prosperity of the labourer consequent upon ample employment
and enhanced rates of wages, enabled him to take up
land for the cultivation of cereal crops in the neighbourhood
of his own village, and hence the supply of labour
declined, those who came to work in the plantations came
later in the season, and altogether the labour supply from
Mysore became more uncertain every year. Planters
consequently, as they had in Mysore itself, had to go
further afield, and now draw labour to a large extent
from the Madras Presidency, the labourers from which in
turn, will now have the means of developing the agricultural
resources of their native villages. This is a point to
which the attention of the Government cannot be too often
drawn with the view of encouraging the opening up, by it,
of every means of stimulating the employment of labour
in India.
Coorg is now fairly well off for labour, and the old
labour difficulties which used to be experienced have to a
great extent disappeared. The average cost of Mysore
labour—men, women, and children, and including the commission
of the Maistries (as the men who collect and bring
the labourers to the estates are called), is from 3 annas 6 pie
to 4 annas a day (or say 5d. to 6d. a day, calculating the rupee
at par, or 2s.). In quite recent times the maistries, who
obtained large sums from the planters to make advances
to the coolies, sometimes absconded with the money and
thereby great losses ensued. But a better class of maistries
have arisen, and Messrs. Matheson and Co. have now,
with the aid of their permanent European labour agent,
established a system of private registration by which the
antecedents, status, and resources of the maistries are
duly recorded. And though the services of doubtful
maistries cannot as yet be altogether dispensed with,
a preference is of course given to those of well
established reputation, and the class of maistries generally
is beginning to understand and appreciate the
system of registration, which has every prospect of becoming
general, and will, I need hardly add, be of great
advantage to planters. But if maistries sometimes swindle
their employers, the former are often liable to be
swindled by the coolies to whom the advances have been
made, and until a system of compulsory Government
registration of advances to coolies is introduced, as recommended
in one of my chapters on coffee planting in
Mysore, it will be impossible to put our peculiar system
of giving advances to coolies on a reasonably safe footing.
The plantations in Coorg have suffered, and still suffer
considerably from leaf disease and Borer, to both of which
I have, for practical purposes, sufficiently alluded in the
chapter on the diseases of coffee. The effects of the
former, though entailing much injury on coffee in Coorg,
have not been so fatal as in Ceylon, as the long stretches
of dry weather, often of four or five months' duration,
seem to kill off large numbers of the spores, and so
mitigate the damage arising from the disease. Messrs.
Matheson and Co., at the instance of the chemist
previously mentioned, sent out Strawsoniser spray
engines for the purpose of treating afflicted trees with
various solutions, but, though good effects were noticeable
on individual trees, it was found that to treat whole estates
in this way was quite impracticable, both from the cost
and the immense amount of labour that would be required,
and this fatal obstacle to the use of such remedies has
been amply proved in Ceylon. But in Coorg the Borer is
much more to be dreaded than leaf disease, and its
ravages are such that even on the best estates fully
twenty-five per cent.[50] of the acreage is under supplies (i.e.,
young plants to take the place of the old ones which have
died), and the late Mr. Pringle—the chemist—was of
opinion that the loss of crop from Borer was not less than
2 cwt. per acre per annum. Before the introduction of
shade the total extermination of an estate was far from
uncommon, the estate in the Bamboo district opened by
Rev. H. A. Kaundinya in 1857 being the first to perish,
and though, as we have seen, owing to the introduction of
shade, the Borer has been largely brought into subjection,
considerable damage still takes place from it. Neither
trouble nor expense has been spared in order to find an
antidote to this pest. Rubbing the stems with the view of
destroying the eggs of the insect, and applying thereto
chemical ingredients have both been tried, but with
very limited results. The late Mr. Pringle's antidote
consisted of the application of two washes of alkali vat
waste, costing five rupees an acre each, but, when carried
into practice, the results were far from what he anticipated.
Taking out the bored trees and burning them has
proved the most effectual way of dealing with the pest, and
would be productive of still better results if native neighbours
would adopt the same practice. But as they will
not adopt this practice, their plantations become nursery
grounds for the propagation of the insect. Many planters
in the Bamboo district pay 1 rupee per hundred for the
Borer fly, and this results in a large number being caught,
but it is not supposed that any appreciable effect has
been produced from this practice.
There can be no doubt, it seems to me, that the primary
cause of the existence of so much Borer was owing to the
planters having at first planted in the open. This must
have created an enormous supply of the insect, which
found a splendid breeding ground in the conditions furnished
by the planters, as is evidenced by the fact of
whole estates having been exterminated by it, and it will
require many years of judicious shading before this insect
can be reduced within comparatively harmless limits. The
reader will observe that I say judicious shading, and I will
more fully explain what I mean by that expression when,
later on in the chapter, I give an account of my tour
through Coorg in 1891, and make some observations on
the proper shading of coffee.
Most of the European estates in Coorg and many of the
larger native plantations are held under what are called
"The Waste Land Rules," under which land is put up
to auction by the State at an upset price of 2 rupees per
acre (10 rupees is the upset price in Mysore), plus the
value of the timber, which adds somewhat to the price.
As a rule there is now considerable competition for land,
and as much as 100 to 150 rupees has frequently to be
paid per acre. The land so purchased is subject to no
assessment up to the fourth year, but from the fourth to the
ninth year 1 rupee is charged, and after that 2 rupees in perpetuity.
The bulk of the land suitable for coffee has been
taken up, though large extents that might be utilized are
included in the State forests, and thus are not available to
the public. Hence there is little room for extension, and
openings for young men with capital are few and far
between, so far as obtaining fresh forest is concerned,
though of course opportunities occasionally occur for purchasing
estates, or acquiring shares in them on various
terms.
And here I would particularly call the attention of the
Government to the following remarks on the reservation
of land in Coorg for State forests, much of which, as we
have seen, might be utilized for coffee.
When, as in former times in Coorg, the planters used no
shade, many good arguments existed in favour of making
very large reserves of forest land in order to prevent
denudation, and its injurious effects on climate, and on
the water supply of the rivers and the country generally.
But when you merely replace the underwood of the forest
with an underwood of coffee which completely covers the
ground, and again shield this from drying winds and the
burning sun by a complete covering of trees, either those
of the original forest or others planted to take their
place, the case is entirely altered, and from the coffee land
thus shaded there is no more loss of water and soil
(perhaps not so much loss of water, as great pains are taken
to avert wash) than there was in the original forest, and
the climatic and conservative effects of forests are therefore
entirely undisturbed. Wherever, then, lands exist
which are suitable for coffee planting under shade, they
should certainly, in the interests of the country generally,
and especially of the rapidly increasing population, be
taken up for coffee, and the State forests be confined to
those tracts which, from over heavy rainfall, or other
causes, are unsuitable for coffee planting.
Other products, and especially cinchona, have received a
fair amount of attention in Coorg, and the land on the
Ghauts to the westward, where, as we have seen, the coffee
plantations have been abandoned, proved to be well suited
for the production of the commoner kinds of bark, and
large extents of abandoned or semi-abandoned lands were
planted with cinchonas. But when the prices of bark fell
(whoever takes to growing a drug will soon realize the
meaning of the phrase "a drug in the market"), the
cultivation was no longer worthy of attention, and has
practically died out. Ceara rubber also met with the same
fate.
I may here mention that Messrs. Matheson and Co.,
who held no less than 7,000 out of the 20,000 acres occupied
by Europeans in the Bamboo district, went to great expense
in introducing coffee seed from Brazil, Venezuela, Costa
Rica, and Jamaica, with the view of ascertaining whether
coffee grown from the seed thus imported would be less susceptible
to attacks of leaf disease. But, though the plants
raised from these seeds are doing exceedingly well, it was
found that they were also liable to be attacked by leaf
disease, often before they were even out of the nursery,
and in this respect proved to be neither better nor worse
than the Coorg variety of coffee. A clearing of fifty acres
has been entirely planted with coffee raised from Blue
Mountain seed, but there is nothing in the appearance of
the trees to show that they are not indigenous to the
country.
Liberian coffee has been tried experimentally in several
parts of Coorg, but I cannot learn that any results have
been obtained which would tend to encourage its adoption
as a substitute for the variety at present grown.
It is estimated that the Coorg planters employ at least
30,000 Mysore labourers in addition to local labourers
and those from the Madras Presidency, and of the 30,000
in question Messrs. Matheson and Co. employ no less than
about 5,000 for six to eight months of the year. The
30,000 coolies, with their maistries, draw from 12 to 15
lakhs of rupees per annum (from £120,000 to £150,000,
estimating the rupee at par, and for the purposes of a
labourer it goes nearly as far in India as when it was
so) in wages, very nearly the whole of which eventually
reaches Mysore either in payment for grain or as a surplus
income which the labourers annually take with them when
they return to their homes in Mysore. And as this capital
is largely employed in developing the agricultural resources
of the Mysore State, it is evident that anything that its
Government could do—in the way of railway extension or
otherwise—that would stimulate the employment of
labour in Coorg would be of great advantage to the
finances of Mysore. It is extremely interesting to follow
the labour-spent capital of the planters of Coorg to its
ultimate destination—to the western coast, to various parts
of the Madras Presidency, and far away into the interior
of Mysore, and to observe its effects on the country and
its financial results. I am not in a position to say exactly
what should be done in the way of railways for Coorg,
but I trust I have sufficiently shown that the British and
Mysore Governments are equally interested in doing all
they can, in the way of railway communication and new
and improved roads, to develop and encourage the planting
resources of Coorg.
The last visit I paid to Coorg was in October, 1891,
immediately after the breaking up of the Representative
Assembly at Mysore, a full account of which I have given
in a previous chapter. I left Mysore on the morning of
Tuesday, October 20th, and on the first day drove to
Hunsur, a town of between four and five thousand inhabitants,
which lies twenty-eight miles to the west of Mysore
city. At this place are the extensive coffee works and
manure preparing establishment of Messrs. Matheson
and Co., by whose manager I was most hospitably and
agreeably entertained. Rather an interesting incident in
connection with a panther had once occurred at his house,
and as this illustrates what I have previously mentioned
as to the (to man) innocuous character of this animal, it
may not be uninteresting to give an account of what
occurred. The circumstances were these.
One night my hostess, some time after retiring to rest,
heard a noise in the open veranda which runs round the
side of the bungalow just outside her bedroom. She
got up, and, taking a lamp in her hand, went round a
corner of the building in the direction of the noise, and
just as she turned the corner in question there fell upon
her astonished vision the spectacle of a panther, which at
the moment was busily engaged in devouring the family
cat. When the panther saw the lady he tried to make off
along the veranda (which at that point was shut in at
the side by a trellis-work), but at the moment of his flight
the cook, who had also heard the noise, appeared at the
opposite end of the veranda with a lamp in his hand. The
panther then turned back in the direction of the lady, who
stood spell-bound with the lamp in her hand, and as the
cook, apparently equally spell-bound, remained stationary
with his lamp, the panther, being thus as it were between
two fires, lay down under a table which was placed
against the wall of the veranda. At last he got up, made
a move in the direction of the cook, and then changing his
mind, rushed past the lady, and thus made his escape.
Panthers seem to be numerous about Hunsur, and I heard
another interesting story of their boldness, which I have
not space to give, from a neighbour of my host.
After staying for a day at Hunsur, I drove, on October
22nd, to Titimutty, a small village on the frontier of Coorg,
where I was met by Mr. Rose, of Hill Grove Estate, who
drove me to his plantation near Polibetta, which is in the
Bamboo district previously alluded to as containing about
two-thirds of the European plantations in Coorg. Shortly
after leaving Titimutty we drove through coffee on both
sides of the road, and, though I spent four days in the
district, and was constantly on the move, I was never once
out of sight of coffee, as the plantations lie in a continuous
block, and, as they are all thoroughly shaded, sometimes by
the original forest trees, and sometimes by trees planted
for shade, the general effect is that you are travelling
through a forest of which coffee is the underwood—a forest
lying on gently undulating ground from which nothing can
be seen of the surrounding country. As the bungalows
of the planters are of course surrounded by coffee and shade
trees, they have necessarily an extremely shut-in appearance.
But this rather triste effect might be obviated (and
I have with good effect obviated it in the case of a bungalow
which lies in the centre of an estate of my own in
Mysore) by cutting vistas here and there through the
shade trees through which peeps may be had of distant
hills. This may seem to be a point of little practical
value, but, as I have shown in a previous chapter, the
amenities of an estate are of value, and are likely to
become more so when the desirable nature of shade coffee
property is more widely known. The bungalows in the
Bamboo district are very comfortable, most of them
having tennis grounds, and if the vistas I have suggested
were cut out, their attractiveness would be much enhanced.
But if the Bamboo district has not the scenic advantages
of plantations in other parts of Coorg and in Mysore, these
are much compensated for by the close proximity of one
plantation to another, and I was told that at certain
seasons there was generally a well-attended lawn tennis
party on every day of the week. There is besides, in the
centre of the district, a comfortable club where balls and
dances are occasionally given. In short, the Bamboo
district has features of its own which make it entirely
different from any planting district in India. From being
so much shut in, it might, at first sight, be supposed
to be not a very healthy district, but I heard no complaints
on that score, nor, from the appearance of the
planters, would it have occurred to me that the district was
at all unhealthy. On the evening of my arrival there was
a dinner-party, at which four ladies were present, and later
on there was music and singing, and all the accompaniments
of a pleasant social life. So much do coffee districts
vary in India, that the party was to me a startling
surprise, which the reader may easily understand when I
mention that, after leaving the most northerly plantation
in Coorg and entering my district of Manjarabad, there is
only one resident lady to be found there, and it is not till
you reach the northern district of Mysore, some sixty miles
further, that ladies, in the plural, again commence, though
even there they do not exist to a very serious extent.
On the afternoon of the day of my arrival I walked
round my host's estate, which carried an excellent crop,
and also visited a neighbouring property. On the following
morning I drove to the Dubarri estate, and walked
round part of it, and in the afternoon visited the club—a
comfortable, and in every respect suitable, building which,
as I mentioned, is occasionally used for dances. I also
visited the co-operative store, which contained a large supply
of various articles. The church, which was close to the
club, had been recently built, at a cost of 5,000 rupees,
but, when I saw it, the interior was not quite finished.
I may mention that in the Bamboo district there is a
resident doctor who is employed by the various estates.
Later on in the afternoon I rode from the club with
Mr. William Davies to the Mattada Kadu estate (Messrs.
Matheson and Co.'s property), of which he is manager, and
rode through coffee all the way to the bungalow. I was
most kindly entertained by Mr. Davies, who had a party
of the neighbouring planters to meet me at dinner,
after which we had much talk on the subject in which
we were all mutually interested. On the following morning
I awoke early, and was rather surprised, shortly after
daylight, to hear the names of the coolies called over from
the check-roll, as, though early hours were kept in the old
days in Mysore, we have now become considerably later,
owing, I surmise, to feeling that in these labour-competing
days we are not as completely master as we once were.
After a small breakfast I rode through the estate, guided
by Mr. Davies, who was accompanied by two of his
guests of the night before, and we then passed into the
Nullagottay estate (all Messrs. Matheson's), after which
we entered into Whust Nullagottay, and went to the
bungalow from which (there is always an exception) there
is a fine view of the Brahmagiri Hills. After a very short
stay we again mounted, and presently passed into the Whoshully
estate, and finally arrived, after riding through
that property, at about midday at Mr. Robinson's bungalow,
where we had breakfast. Mr. Rose came over in the
afternoon, and we rode home to Hill Grove through Messrs.
Matheson's estate which had been bought from Mr.
Minchin, besides visiting the Hope estate. I thus rode
through coffee for nearly the entire day. On the following
day I went over another adjacent property, and on the
day after, Monday, October 26th, started for Mercara, the
capital of Coorg. I drove by way of Siddapur, paid a
short visit to Cannon Kadu estate, and arrived at Abiel,
Mr. Martin's estate, at about midday, rode round his
estate in the afternoon, and then drove on to Mr. E.
Meynell's charming home—the Retreat—which is about a
mile from the town of Mercara.
I was particularly struck with the arrangements of this
house, as it was a thoroughly English-looking home in
every respect, and I only wish I could give a plan of it as
a model for a residence in the hill and planting districts
of India. The front veranda was inclosed with glass, and
lined with flowers in pots, and from the centre of this
projected a conservatory, at the end of which was the
front door. You thus, after driving up to the house,
walked through a conservatory into the inclosed veranda,
and this not only gave a very pretty effect, but was practically
useful by keeping carriages, with their attendant
dust and disagreeables, at a sufficient distance from the
veranda. My hostess very kindly permitted me to see the
kitchen arrangements. These, as well as the storerooms,
were in a wing projecting from the back of the bungalow.
The kitchen, which consisted of a separate room, with a
single door, was furnished with a Wilson range, and there
was no door between the kitchen and the scullery. The
latter was at the outside edge of the wing, and was
entered by its own door—an arrangement, by the way, that
might be practised with advantage in this country, as a
connecting door is liable to admit smells from the scullery
into the kitchen. The reader will, I trust, excuse the
mention of these apparently trivial matters, but as I
strongly suspect that much of the ill-health in India is
due to the dirt and horrors of the Indian cook-room, which
is usually at a little distance from the bungalow, and
turned into a general lounge for the servants, I think it
well to show that, with a little contrivance and attention,
as great a degree of order and cleanliness may exist in
India as in any other portion of the globe.
On the following day I called on Mr. Mann, son of one
of the pioneer planters of 1855, and inspected an interesting
coffee garden of four acres which is close to his bungalow
in Mercara. Some of the coffee trees were planted
thirty and others forty years ago, and they have given for
many years fifteen hundredweight an acre on the average,
and though many of the trees were evidently suffering from
the effects of overbearing, there seemed no reason why
they should not continue to bear good crops for an indefinite
period of time. Estimating the value of the coffee at
80s. a hundredweight, the produce of an acre would be
worth £60, of 100 acres £6,000, and allowing one-half for
expenses—a very liberal estimate—there would be a clear
income of £3,000 a year from 100 acres of such coffee. As
100 acres of land so situated—it was flat, lay in a hollow,
and was well sheltered—could not be obtained, it might
seem that an account of this garden could be of no practical
value. But the garden in question raises one very important
point in the mind, and that is whether it would not
be better to abandon all inferior soils and situations on
an estate, and concentrate all the labour and manurial
resources on a more limited area, every operation on which
could be carried out exactly at the right moment. This is
a highly important question which I state here for the
consideration of planters.
After spending two pleasant days at the Retreat, I bade
my kind host and hostess good-bye (I have thanked Mr.
Meynell, who I may mention represents Messrs. Matheson's
large interests in Coorg, in the preface for the valuable
information he subsequently sent me as regards planting
in Coorg), and went on my way towards my home in Mysore,
and stayed first at the Hallery estate, which is about six
miles from Mercara, and is the property of my friend Mr.
Mangles. The approach to the bungalow through the
coffee is very pretty; the building stands at the head of a
slope, and commands a fine and extensive view of the
country and the distant hills. The amenities here had
been well attended to: below the front of the bungalow
terraces edged with balustrades had been cut, and
formed into flower gardens, and I was glad to see that, in
parts of the plantation, from which good views could be
had, there were seats. I may observe here that there is a
great want in plantations of seats, which are now the more
needed as all logs in the old plantations have of course
disappeared. Near the bungalow is an excellent stable,
well paved, and quite in English style. On the following
morning I wont with Mr. Sprott, who is in charge of Mr.
Mangles's estate, to visit his Santigherry property, some
seven miles distant, and on the way there went on the left
of the road through a plantation belonging to Messrs.
Macpherson and Ainslie. After this we re-entered the main
road, passed the village of Santikoopa, and then entered
and went round the estate we had come to visit. On the
way home we diverged to the left and went through Mr.
Murray Ainslie's estate, and round by an estate owned by
Mr. Campbell, and finally arrived at Hallery at about half-past
twelve. In the afternoon I went round part of the
estate, which I had already seen something of on the day
of my arrival.
Early the following morning, after bidding good-bye to the
host and hostess who had so kindly entertained me, I started
on my journey northwards, and after a troublesome and
trying drive (for my horses), in which two rivers had to be
crossed by ferry boats, and much deep unmetalled road
struggled through, I arrived at 12.30 at Coovercolley—another
estate of Mr. Mangles's—where I was kindly entertained
by Mr. and Mrs. Trelawney (Mr. Trelawney manages
this fine property). The bungalow here is particularly
comfortable, and had the great advantage of a very wide
open veranda. On the right of the approach to the bungalow
was a neatly trimmed shoe flower hedge, which had
a very pretty effect, and, as at Hallery, terraces had been
cut in front for a flower garden. From the front of the
bungalow there is an extensive view of much of the Coorg
country, and I was particularly struck by its continuous
jungly character, and with its great contrast to the Mysore
country to the north, which is not so much a jungly
country, as an open grass country studded with occasional
wood, and park-like groups of trees. On the afternoon of
my arrival I rode round part of this fine estate, and inspected
other parts of it on the following morning and
evening. On the next morning I started at a quarter to
six, and after driving about twenty-four miles, crossed the
frontier, and entered Manjarabad—the southernmost coffee
district of Mysore. The northernmost part of Coorg consists
of a long tongue of land which projects into Mysore,
and the scenery, in its beautiful, open, and park-like character,
naturally resembles that of Manjarabad.
On my visit to Coorg I look back with pleasure. It was,
indeed, extremely enjoyable and instructive, and I cannot
help regretting the fact that, owing to the nature of their
duties, planters are obliged to remain so continuously at
home; and then, of course, when they can get away, they
naturally go for change of air and scene anywhere out of the
coffee districts. The result of this is that the planters of
the north of Mysore see little of those in the south, and
that neither have any intercourse with Coorg, and that, in
consequence, much valuable interchange of views and experiences
that might otherwise take place cannot now do
so. Had such intercourse existed, many of the mistakes
made in Coorg as regards shade would probably have been
avoided, and much loss of money averted.
The reader will have noticed that I have hitherto made
no observations on the coffee I saw in Coorg, my reason
for not doing so being that I thought they might be more
conveniently reserved for the close of the chapter. I am
glad that in the course of my observations I shall have
much to say in praise of the state of coffee in Coorg, and
if I should seem to be a little free in my remarks as to the
management of shade, I trust that my Coorg readers will
bear in mind that my experience of trees planted as shade
to supply the place of original forest trees removed is the
oldest in India, and stretches back to the year 1857, and
that it requires a very long time, as they will see by consulting
the chapter on shade, before all the points connected
with shade trees can be proved with certainty. That mistakes
as regards shade should have been made in Coorg,
where shade experience is comparatively recent, is not at
all surprising; in former times numerous mistakes were
made in Mysore, and have only been rectified by long
experience and observation.
My general impression on going through the Bamboo
district of Coorg was that it contains a certain proportion
of land of poor character (and this can be said of most
coffee districts) which should never have been opened, but
that there are many excellent and valuable estates, though
it was plain to me that, from the more weakly, or perhaps
I should rather say less robust, character of the shoots, and
the appearance of the soil, it had, as a rule, much less
growing power in it, and would consequently require more
manure, than the deep and heavier soils of Mysore. But
these soils in the Bamboo district, though lighter in
character, are of course (and this is a fact of no small
importance) more easily worked than those of Mysore.
The next point that attracted my attention was the shade,
and of the numerous estates that I saw in the Bamboo
district there were only two that at all came up to my idea
of what a well shaded property ought to be. I could see
little signs of the shade being varied in kind and quantity
to suit the various aspects, and many trees were preserved
which were merely throwing shadow, not on to the coffee,
but on to adjacent trees. Then I found that in one
excellent piece of young coffee the shade had been planted
in lines running from east to west, instead of being closely
planted in lines from north to south (vide chapter on
shade). The shade, too, generally speaking, was far too
largely composed of one kind of tree,—the Attí-mara
(Ficus glomerata)—and finally this tree, the defects of
which I have remarked upon in my chapter on shade,
was badly managed by being trimmed up to a considerable
height above the ground. The result of this was that on
land on which there was an enormous number of trees
there was far too little shade, and a forester fresh from
England would never have imagined that the planters had
intended to grow umbrageous trees for the double purpose
of lowering the temperature of the plantation and sheltering
the coffee from sun and parching winds, but would
have supposed that they were engaged in growing timber
for sale. I saw land which, I feel sure, had at least three
times the number of trees that would have been sufficient
to shade it fully, had they been properly treated. Such a
number of trees throw out, of course, a corresponding
number of large roots, and one planter told me that in
some instances coffee was being killed by the masses of
Attí root in the land. As regards shade, then, there is
much room for improvement in Coorg, and especial attention
should be paid to this in the Bamboo district which
has suffered so much from Borer. This pest, we know,
thrives best under warm and dry conditions, and it is
therefore of great importance that the kinds of shade
most recommended in my chapter on shade should be
freely planted, and other kinds gradually removed.
There was a very good crop on the trees when I passed
through Coorg—one that, when picked, quite exceeded the
expectations of the planters—and I saw two estates which
had at once a good crop on the trees, leaves of good, well-fed
looking colour, and a show of wood giving promise of
an equally good crop for the following year; and it says well
for cultivation in Coorg that any estate could show this, for
the tendency of coffee, as of most fruit trees, is to give
heavy and light crops alternately. As it is important to
know the manures that were used to produce such results,
I may mention that on one of these estates 6 cwt. of castor
cake and 3 cwt. of bones had been applied the previous
year, and for the four preceding years 2 cwt. of castor
cake and 1 cwt. of bone had been used, but, in the opinion
of the manager, the latter application had proved too
small. On the other estate one-third of a bushel of cattle
manure per tree, and from 7 cwt. to 10 cwt. of bones had
been applied once in three years, and composts also had
been used to a considerable extent. These were formed
first of a layer of vegetable rubbish, then fresh pulp and
lime, and lastly a layer of soil. The estate last referred to,
on which the cattle manure, bones and compost had been
used, belongs to Mr. Mangles—his Coovercolley estate—and
is certainly the finest I ever saw, if we take into consideration
the state of the soil, the colour of the foliage,
and the evident prospect of continuously good crops. So
well fed, indeed, was the land with nitrogen, that an application
of nitrate of soda produced no perceptible effect on
the trees. The land was probably over supplied with
phosphoric acid, and an analysis of the soil would be
of practical value, for if, as I have good reason to surmise,
there is a very large supply of phosphoric acid in the soil,
the use of bones might be suspended for some years, and
a light application of lime used instead. Ten acres, at any
rate, might be tried as an experiment. I was shown one
piece of coffee which had been manured, when it was two
years old, with cattle manure, and this piece had remained
perceptibly superior ever since. On this estate 600 cattle
are kept for the sake of their manure. I would suggest
that the proprietor might, on say ten acres, discontinue the
use of cattle manure, and, as an experiment, apply dressings
of jungle top-soil instead, or the red earth alluded to in my
chapter on manures, should that be available. The experiment
might be valuable to the proprietor and to planters in
general. Cattle manure is very expensive, and when 12 to
14 tons per acre—some fairly well rotted and some slightly
so—were used in Coorg on one estate the cost was 72 rupees
an acre, including cost of application.
In bringing these brief remarks to a close, I may observe
that I formed a very high opinion of coffee in Coorg,
and I feel confident that if the shade were remodelled
on the system recommended in my chapter on that
subject, the losses from Borer and leaf disease would be
largely diminished, and a great general improvement in the
coffee take place. We have experienced such results from
improved shade in Mysore, and there can be no doubt
that similar results will follow in Coorg. In remodelling
the shade system, all light and dry soils should be first
attended to and planted up with trees which give an ample
and cool shade. The treatment of other parts of plantations
may be postponed.
As regards the profits that may reasonably be expected
from well managed and well situated estates in Coorg, I
am happy to say that I have obtained from a friend the
returns from his estates for the last ten years, and as his
properties are of large extent, the return may be regarded
as a very reliable one, more especially as the prices for three
years of the period were very low. The average yield per
acre was 4 cwt. 1 qr. 7 lbs.; the expenses, £9 4s. 2d., and
the profits per acre £7 8s. 6d.
I only wish that, in conclusion, I could give as favourable
an account of the prospects of sport in Coorg as I can of
its coffee. Twenty-five years ago there was good big game
shooting, but the absence of game laws, and the indiscriminate
destruction of does, fawns, and cow bisons by the
natives, at every season of the year, have changed all that,
and it is with a melancholy smile that one reads in the
"Coorg Gazetteer" that the Coorgs are such ardent sportsmen
that they have hardly left a head of game in the
country. But the first sign of advanced civilization—the
intelligent preservation of wild animals—has begun, or
will shortly be begun, in the enlightened state of Mysore,
and I trust that its good example may soon be followed in
Coorg, and all parts of India. With the aid of preservation
game will soon increase in the more remote forests
into which it has been driven back, and from thence spread
into other parts of the country.
[48] "Manual of Coorg," compiled by Rev. G. Richter, Principal,
Government Central College, Mercara. Mangalore, 1870.
[49] The late Mr. William Pringle, who, after leaving Coorg, wrote
in 1891, for the "Madras Mail," some interesting and suggestive
papers on the cultivation of coffee.
[50] I make this statement on the authority of Mr. Meynell (vide
preface), and it is, no doubt, the result of his experience in the
Bamboo district, but his estimate could hardly, I should say, apply
to the estates I visited in North Coorg.
Categories:
Articles |